Review
After the film, Ben and I went and got a drink and an appetizer to debrief everything…
Holy hell, that was absolutely the best film of the year, and I have so many thoughts.
It was part documentary, part detective investigator who-done-it mystery, part comedy, part scripted, part unscripted, and part narrative... Overall wild af. The amount of twists are insane.
One of the main insane things about this film is the quality of the visuals are literally just top notch. The cinematography in this film is unfair that it's “just a documentary” because it has some of the best frames of the year. Literally at one point, Ben looked at me and said, “I think I'm watching the best film ever I've ever seen.”
I think I said “WTF?!” 8 different ways, at least 40 times throughout this film. Because it truly is just mind-blowing where this story goes.
And I don't know what's real and what's not real anymore. I truly don't know what's real or not real anymore. Humans are just so interesting. You feel for everyone in this film at some point, which is just absurd cause some of these peeps deserve NO FEELS. Documentary filmmaking is so incredible because, like street photography, you just have to be there to capture the moment. You have to have a camera and you have to be educated and trained well enough to capture the video and the audio in these fleeting yet absolutely captivating moments.
There are so many moments where you just cannot believe the amount of access that this crew had to Elizabeth and her family. It feels unreal; the story is truly unreal, especially because you are left with this feeling of just not knowing what to believe.
There were certainly times where I realized that this film was long, but I was never not engaged. And then the film just pushes again - another gear to accelerate even faster to an unbelievable scenario. You think it's done, you think it's gonna wrap up, or you think that there just can't be any more twists… But the film just continues to progress forward. It's like being on the VelociCoaster - You think that you're going so damn fast, and you think there’s just no way you could go any faster… And then you go even faster.
That's that feeling that I had, but in the sense I'm watching this of just being like, ‘I think I gotta figure it out, I think I know what's happening, I think I'm aligned with somebody, I think I'm like rooting for someone, I think I've got these people figured out’
You don’t.
I’m so glad I watched this in a theater on opening night/weekend. The theater was pretty much packed. Our showing was actually selected for a screening survey with A24 (or one of their partners) to provide immediate feedback about the film. But just being present in a room with strangers all reacting at the same time was so much fun. People really are returning to the theater, which is great because shared experiences are so unique. This film is an example as to why filmmakers are fighting so much to keep theater presence despite the rise of streaming. As humans, experiencing moments in groups with strangers is important because we can learn so much from one another. We’re all so different, yet so similar as we laugh or gasp at the same time.
There's one point in the film where I literally leaned in to get closer to what I was witnessing. I sat up in my reclining chair in this theater, leaned forward and put my elbows to my knees so I could rest my chin on the palms of my hand because I was so just dumbfounded and flabbergasted by the development in the film. And I know the guy next to me was just like, ‘What the hell is wrong with this guy?’ - I was so locked in.
It felt like the same thing as watching Star Wars or Avengers: Endgame in the theater. This film just has that type of hook, or catch, or just that unique element to it that makes witnessing it with strangers for the first time so incredible and unrepeatable.
It was awesome. Go watch it.